The Artemi Panarin Dilemma: A Franchise-Altering Decision for the Rangers

0 Sara Smith August 28, 2025

The bright lights of Broadway have a way of illuminating both brilliance and blemishes. For Artemi Panarin, his tenure with the New York Rangers has been a masterclass in offensive wizardry, a spectacle of skill that has often left the Garden faithful breathless. Yet, as the final year of his mammoth contract dawns, a shadow of postseason disappointment looms large, forcing a question that could define the next era of Rangers hockey: to re-sign or to rebuild?

NHL insider Frank Seravalli’s recent suggestion that the Rangers will attempt to extend Panarin is a vote of confidence in a roster that has been retooled and is desperate for a bounce-back season. On the surface, the idea of letting a player of Panarin’s caliber walk for nothing is unthinkable. He’s the offensive heartbeat of this team, a perennial Hart Trophy candidate, and a player who can single-handedly change the course of a game. But the playoffs are a different beast, and the lack of a Stanley Cup ring during his time in New York is a glaring omission on his otherwise stellar resume.

A Crossroads for the Rangers and the Breadman

General Manager Chris Drury is not one to sit on his hands. His aggressive moves since last season are a clear indication that the status quo is not acceptable. The upcoming season is, therefore, an audition for everyone, Panarin included. If the Rangers come out flying, re-establishing themselves as a legitimate contender, then a contract extension for Panarin, albeit at a potentially lower cap hit, makes a world of sense.

However, if the team falters and finds itself on the outside looking in come the NHL trade deadline, Drury could be forced to make the unthinkable choice: trade Panarin to a contender and recoup assets for a quick retool. The pressure is on, and how Panarin and the Rangers perform this season will have a domino effect that will be felt for years to come.