When the New Jersey Devils made the surprising decision to list Dougie Hamilton as a healthy scratch against the Winnipeg Jets, the NHL rumor mill didn’t just whisper—it screamed. For a defenseman of his offensive pedigree to sit in the press box signals one of two things: a complete breakdown in trust or imminent asset management. With reports surfacing that Hamilton’s agent is working with the Devils to facilitate a move, eyes are turning toward Music City.
The Nashville Predators have clawed their way back into wildcard contention after a sluggish start to the season. GM Barry Trotz made his intentions clear in the summer of 2024 by signing Steven Stamkos and Jonathan Marchessault: the window is now. Adding Hamilton to a blue line already anchored by Roman Josi isn’t just a move; it’s a declaration of war on the Western Conference. But does the reward outweigh the massive risk?
Analyzing the Fit: Hamilton and the Predators Blue Line
From an “armchair GM” perspective, the hockey fit is tantalizing. Imagine a power play unit featuring Roman Josi and Dougie Hamilton patrolling the blue line, feeding one-timers to Stamkos. Hamilton has always been an elite play-driver; his ability to exit the zone with possession fits the modern NHL meta perfectly. If you pair him with Josi, you arguably have the most dynamic offensive defense pairing in the league.
However, as an analyst, I have to look at the cap sheet. The Predators are already arguably the boldest experiment in the league regarding “aging gracefully.” They have committed significant dollars and term to veterans. Bringing in Hamilton—who is 32 and carries a hefty cap hit—compounds the issue that skeptics have flagged since July 2024: The Predators are old, and they are expensive.
Josh Wegman of The Score correctly notes that Nashville has already saddled itself with difficult-to-move contracts. For this to work, the New Jersey Devils would likely need to retain salary (perhaps up to 50%), or take a bad contract back. Would New Jersey do that just to move on? Maybe. But for Nashville, adding another 30-plus star is doubling down on a strategy that has zero safety net. If they miss the playoffs or exit early, this roster construction could haunt the franchise for a half-decade.
Yet, if Hamilton arrives and clicks? That transition game becomes lethal. It’s the kind of high-stakes gambling that makes the NHL trade deadline the best time of year.
Latest Nashville Predators News & Fantasy Pool
Don’t miss a beat of this developing story. For the absolute latest Nashville Predators news, roster updates, and game breakdowns, make sure you keep it locked here. Think you know more than the GMs? Prove it. Join our Fantasy Hockey Pool for cash prizes—spots are filling up fast! Also, looking for how to watch the Preds game on TV today? We have full broadcast listings on our website. Add nhltraderumor.com to your bookmarks today and sign up for our newsletter below so you never miss a trade alert.
The post Is Dougie Hamilton the Missing Piece for a Predators Playoff Run? appeared first on NHL Trade Rumors.
